was reading a blurb on the CBS Holmes series Elementary, where the writer said (paraphrased) that he wants Holmes in NY (other than to make it cheaper to shoot) because Holmes is always shown as ‘brilliant and ten steps ahead of anyone else’ but he wanted to make it so that Holmes has to be in a place that’s difficult for anyone to live in.’ Believe it or not, as a former resident I know London has industrial areas, slums and gangs along with its museums and palaces, just like any other large metropolitan capital in the world. I wonder how New Yorkers would feel about their city being ‘difficult’ to live in. You could see NY as being a ‘hard city’ as a trope before 9/11 but it doesn’t have the same cultural resonance now.
The only difference I see in moving Holmes is he knows London inside and out, it would take some time to learn the streets, form a version of the Irregulars, etc. But Holmes in time could do that anywhere, if you are true to the character. Holmes in Tokyo or Moscow, :D that would be more difficult. But yeah, we all know why they moved the location.
Incidentally, there is a modern Sherlock series in production in Russia, I believe set in Moscow, I’m excited about that. If you want to see a great Sherlock-esque detective in Tokyo, try the excellent series Mr.Brain.
As an aside, no matter how this show does it’s always going to be compared to Sherlock, which over here, would be a good boost. I’m not gonna have to count all the articles that say, yeah, but have you seen the one they’ve done on the BBC?
The only difference I see in moving Holmes is he knows London inside and out, it would take some time to learn the streets, form a version of the Irregulars, etc. But Holmes in time could do that anywhere, if you are true to the character. Holmes in Tokyo or Moscow, :D that would be more difficult. But yeah, we all know why they moved the location.
Incidentally, there is a modern Sherlock series in production in Russia, I believe set in Moscow, I’m excited about that. If you want to see a great Sherlock-esque detective in Tokyo, try the excellent series Mr.Brain.
As an aside, no matter how this show does it’s always going to be compared to Sherlock, which over here, would be a good boost. I’m not gonna have to count all the articles that say, yeah, but have you seen the one they’ve done on the BBC?