R is for Rough - Review Dog Dean Afternoon

grade D

we knew the premise was ridiculous, but past comedy episodes (by Ben Edlund) only make you wish to heaven they only let Ben Edlund handle them. This episode had all the depth of a Scooby Doo episode, one villian, easy clues, slapstick, with one truly funny moment ( Read more... )

The Road So Far - Supernatural Season Nine (jury out on calling it Fine)

I Think I'm Gonna Like It Here - Season Premiere - Dean prays to angels to save Sam, Cas makes a friend. Grade A, sets up this main season arc and premise intrigues, but more personal than grand goal 'such as save the world, find the tablet, shut the gates, etc.'

Devil May Care - Dean and Sam are suckered into a ghost town to discover their new/old nemesis. Grade B-, we get a great return of an old freind, but the mechanism for getting there is clunky with disposable hunter sidekicks.

I'm No Angel - the adventures of human Castiel, brought to you by the worst writing duo on the show, with expected results, Cas now two for two on stabbing deaths. Grade D lifted up from fail for Misha and Jensen performances.

Slumber Party - a little trip to Oz for Sam, Dean, Charlie and Dorothy Gale/Baum. Grade B a little bit of whimsy.

Dog Dean Afternoon - Dean takes a potion which allows him to hear the voices of animals ... with side effects. Jensen makes it watchable. Grade C-